Following Singapore’s lead in the race to become Asia’s leading Fintech hub, the Hong Kong Monetary Authority (HKMA) has launched a Fintech Supervisory Sandbox (FSS). The FSS aims to allow banks to pilot trials of Fintech and other technological initiatives in a controlled environment with a more flexible supervisory arrangement before they are launched on a fuller scale. Fintech technologies covered by the FSS include mobile payment services, biometric authentication, blockchain, robotics and augmented reality.

Details of the FSS are set out in the HKMA’s circular of 6 September 2016.

General Principles Governing the FSS

The HKMA has set out the following principles for the FSS:

  • The FSS is available to Fintech as well as other technology initiatives intended to be launched in Hong Kong by authorized institutions (AIs);
  • Within the FSS, an AI is allowed to conduct a pilot trial of its initiatives involving actual banking services and a limited number of participating customers (such as staff members or focus groups of selected customers) without the need to achieve full compliance with the HKMA’s usual supervisory requirements during the trial period. However this is predicated on the understanding that the management of the AI will ensure that:
    • BoundaryThere are clear definitions about the scope and phases (if any) of the trial (such as the size and types of customers involved, technologies and types of banking services covered), the timing and the termination arrangements;
    • Customer Protection MeasuresAdequate measures are in place to protect the interests of the customers during the trial. These measures should in general include a proper process for selecting customers who understand the associated risks and voluntarily join the trial, enhanced complaint handling procedures, a mechanism for timely and fair compensation of customers’ financial losses caused by any failures of the trial and appropriate arrangements for customers to withdraw from the trial;
    • Risk Management ControlsReasonable compensating controls are implemented to mitigate the risks arising from less than full compliance with supervisory requirements, and to address the risks (including cyber attacks and system disruptions) posed by the trial run to the AI’s production systems and customers who do not join the trial; and
    • Readiness and MonitoringThe systems and processes involved are ready for the trial (such as after going through reasonable testing and other rollout preparation). In addition, the trial is subject to close monitoring so that the AI can promptly identify and handle any significant problems or incidents that may arise (including matters about public and customer communications); and
  • The FSS should not be used by AIs as a means to bypass applicable supervisory requirements.

FSS Objectives

The stated aims of the FSS’ more flexible supervisory arrangement are to enable AIs to conduct live tests of their new Fintech and innovative technologies more swiftly and in advance of their formal launch; to enhance the ease with which AIs can gather real-life data and user feedback in a controlled environment; and to allow AIs to make refinements as appropriate.

HKMA to Discuss Supervisory Flexibility with Banks Individually

The HKMA does not intend to set out an exhaustive list of the supervisory requirements that may potentially be relaxed within the FSS, such as security-related requirements for electronic banking services and the timing of independent assessment prior to launching new technology services. AIs intending to access the FSS are advised to contact the HKMA early as discussions regarding the appropriate supervisory flexibility will be held on an individual basis. The HKMA has made clear its intentions to refine the FSS arrangement over time in light of implementation experience and industry development.

Hong Kong Positioning as a Fintech Hub

While Singapore’s Monetary Authority moved aggressively to attract Fintech start-ups, Hong Kong has been perceived as being slow off the starting block. A report by Ernst & Young in February 2016 ranked Hong Kong last of seven major hubs worldwide. Singapore was ranked fourth after Britain, New York and California. Hong Kong’s Financial Services and Treasury Bureau has stressed that it will ensure a balance between market innovation and ensuring investor understanding and risk tolerance. The FSTB has also referenced Hong Kong’s unique position vis-à-vis the Mainland, such as CEPA, as a key attraction for overseas Fintech companies.

Non-AIs and the SFC Fintech Contact Point

The HKMA’s FSS is however limited to AIs. The activities of non-AIs which are regulated by the Securities and Futures Commission (SFC) must comply with the requirements of the Securities and Futures Ordinance, its subsidiary legislation and relevant Codes of Conduct. The SFC has however established a Fintech Contact Point and individuals and firms interested in starting or developing Fintech business may contact it at to discuss relevant regulatory implications.

Hong Kong Fintech Supervisory Sandbox FSS

Supervisory requirements and flexibility

Hong Kong fintech hub

HKMA FSS

HKMA supervisory requirements

Fintech Supervisory Sandbox

Fin Tech Finance

Fin Tech News

FSS objectives

Charltons Boutique Transactional Law Firm of the Year 2017
Asian Legal Business Awards

This newsletter is for information purposes only. Its contents do not constitute legal advice and it should not be regarded as a substitute for detailed advice in individual cases. Transmission of this information is not intended to create and receipt does not constitute a lawyer-client relationship between Charltons and the user or browser. Charltons is not responsible for any third party content which can be accessed through the website. If you do not wish to receive this newsletter please let us know by emailing us at unsubscribe@charltonslaw.com

Charltons
Dominion Centre, 12th Floor
43-59 Queen’s Road East Hong Kong
Tel: + (852) 2905 7888
Fax: + (852) 2854 9596
https://www.charltonsquantum.com
Charltons Quantum - 2018